Episode Transcript

One

The Story of Irene Gut Opdyke

During World War II, a woman named Irene Gut Opdyke managed to smuggle a significant number of Jewish persons to safety.ย Unfortunately, a Nazi officer found out what she was doing and he made her this proposal:ย If she would become his mistress, he wouldnโ€™t blow the whistle on her activities.

So she took his deal. Needless to say, she had no desire to be intimate with such a monster, but she thought it was worth it to save the lives of innocent people. She thought the important consequences of her work justified the repulsive bargain.

This seems, at first glance, to be a very courageous decision. But, on the other hand, courage is a virtue, and virtue can only prompt us to do what is morally good.

And fornication isnโ€™t morally good. So how do we deal with decisions that look brave but are actually immoral?ย 

Two

We all try to maximize good consequences โ€“ and weโ€™re all willing to put up with some unpleasant consequences

The first thing to notice is that everyone acts with an eye to consequences. We all try to make choices, or we should, that make the world overall a better place. Itโ€™s also true that most decisions involve pros and cons. There are always tradeoffs.ย Usually, we have to be willing to put up with some unpleasant side-effects from our decisions for the sake of the more important good weโ€™re trying to do. You canโ€™t make an omelet without breaking a few eggs, as the saying goes.

So does that mean that as long as our intentions are good, and we really think our actions are going to bring about the best consequences overall and we really are not motivated by the morally repugnant aspect of the thing, in that case can we just go ahead?

No. Absolutely not.ย ย 

Three

Difference between principle of double effect and consequentialism

Itโ€™s very important to be clear on the difference betweenย the principle of double effect, which is a legitimate principle in moral theology, and consequentialism, which goes directly against the Churchโ€™s moral teaching.ย 

The principle of double effect says you can do something that will probably have some undesirable consequences if

  1. The immediate action โ€“ or the means โ€“ itself isnโ€™t sinfulย 

  2. The undesirable consequences are not willed as a means or an end,ย 

  3. The good consequences seem (as far as one can tell) to outweigh the bad consequences,ย 

  4. There doesnโ€™t seem to be a better, morally permissible alternative.ย 

So Irene Opdykeโ€™s decision to fornicate with the Nazi officer clearly fails that first condition. Her means for getting him to look the other way was intrinsically evil. Consequentialism says you can do anything, including directly attacking human goodness, if you think itโ€™ll bring about greater consequences overall.

So hereโ€™s the basic difference between the principle of double effect and consequentialism: the principle of double effect says, โ€œDo something good with the hope that in the long run there will be more good consequences than bad consequences.โ€ The principle of double effect starts out with a concrete good and then hopes for the possible future good. Itโ€™s like taking a hundred dollars and putting it in the bank with the hope that it will generate interest and make you even more money.

Consequentialism, on the contrary, says, โ€œDo something evil with the hope that in the long run, there will be more good consequences than bad consequences.โ€ Consequentialism starts out with destroying a concrete good and then hopes for the possible future good. It is like taking a hundred dollars and ripping it to pieces with the hope that it will make you even more money. Obviously, that doesnโ€™t make much sense, which is why consequentialism has consistently been rejected by Catholic teaching.

Four

Bringing about the best consequences within a morally acceptable range of choices

We all want good consequences. We all want to find ways to make the world a better place. The great challenge of the moral life is to do that within a morally acceptable range of options.

We all want to help ease the pain of suffering people. But we have to look for ways to do that apart from Euthanasia. We all want family members to know we love them and support them, but we have to look for ways to do that apart from endorsing or celebrating their dysfunctional lifestyle decisions. We all want to reform the Church but we have to look for ways to do that apart from attacking the Pope and undermining the authority Christ has given to the successor of Peter and the Apostles.

Because even pursuing a noble, good end, doesnโ€™t justify directly attacking what is good.

Five

True Courage: Trust in Godย 

True courage, virtuous courage, means pursuing a noble goal through righteous means.ย That takes courage, because there are times when there donโ€™t seem to be any righteous means available for achieving our noble goal.

Irene Opdyke didnโ€™t see any way to save lives without the gravely sinful means of yielding to the Naziโ€™s lust.ย But this is why trust in God is the greatest source of courage. It assures us that even if we canโ€™t see any clear, moral path leading to the greater good, God is in control.

So when it feels like weโ€™ve run out of viable options, we leave it to Him. Knowing that He will do greater good for the world with our fidelity and purity than we could ever do by compromising what we know to be right.

If you enjoyed this meditation, subscribe below.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Elise Delaney 2 years ago

Thank you !!!

Avatar

Kelly L.2 years ago

I propose this article to you by a source I greatly respect. Catholic moral teaching is not always cut and dried. https://www.firstthings.com/article/2011/06/fig-leaves-and-falsehoods

Avatar

Kelly L.2 years ago

If she had not succumbed to his lust she likely would have been killed herself and the Jews she would have saved would have died as well. This is a tough one.

Avatar

Charles Machado2 years ago

Do you mean to say that it is much better to let hundreds of Jews to die than to safeguard your chastity? What about St Maximillian Kolbe, did he not knowingly give his life up to save another life? Was he morally justified to do this?

Avatar

Stewart Bofenkamp2 years ago

This is a difficult one to understand. In war how would this teaching apply to soldiers on either side who kill their enemy on the other side? Would Irene have been justified in killing the Nazi to protect her life and the Jews she was protecting?

Avatar

Rosemary Mayberry 2 years ago

Disagree Lives were saved โ€ฆ Her โ€œSinโ€ was Certainly Forgiven..!

Avatar

Thomas Holden2 years ago

We should not judge a personโ€™s actions when they are subjected to what is tantamount to a moral dilemma. Only God the Supreme judge can do this. Have you never heard of forgiveness?

Avatar

Carolina Boado2 years ago

According to dictionary meaning, It is fornication if you have sex without marriage. Fornication is a crime but also considered just a misdemeanour or wrongdoing. But she Irene did make a big sacrifice and probably decided to do so in panic, no chance to think clearly, and her immediate aim is to save those people.

Avatar

Maura Kelley2 years ago

How does that apply to daily life?

Avatar

Rory Carrick2 years ago

She chose and by that was a victim, and the only one, of the nazi. It was not fornication! She made a huge sacrifice. Sorry, for once I disagree with you

Avatar

Isabel Garcia 2 years ago

๐Ÿ™๐Ÿ™๐Ÿ™Awesome

Avatar

Janet M.2 years ago

So what, exactly, was Irene supposed to do?

Avatar

christine green2 years ago

Thank you for your mediation and rosery.some thing about this a hard one .God bless Mike and Teresa ๐Ÿ™๐Ÿ™Œ๐Ÿ™ amen ๐Ÿ™

Avatar

Erica Meyer2 years ago

This is a hard one for me. Thank you for the explanation.

Avatar

C R2 years ago

I disagree. Her immediate action was to save lives. The undesirable consequence was physical and mental torture. The Nazis bedroom was the lions den.